International Journal of Transportation Engineering

International Journal of Transportation Engineering

Drivers' speed choice behavior considering drivers' demographic characteristics: A driving simulator study

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
Mehdi Zolali 1
Babak Mirbaha 1
Arman Saffarzadeh 2
1 Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin, Iran
2 Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
10.22119/ijte.2021.283072.1566
Abstract
The present study investigates the Iranian drivers’ characteristics and tries to determine which factors can affect the drivers’ speed selection behavior. Therefore, drivers’ who choose speeds higher than the 85th percentile speed were examined, mainly because of the importance and effectiveness of higher speeds in crash occurrence in Iranian roads. For this purpose, a driving simulator was used to conduct the research and gathering the drivers’ selected speed while driving in scenarios. Six scenarios were used in the driving simulator based on the visibility conditions, and 70 participants were evaluated through the driving simulator. Using the t-test, speed data differences in six scenarios have proved. Results showed that age, education level, and gender affect drivers' perception of speed and speed selection. The age of the participants affected the selected speed negatively, which means that increases in the drivers' age can cause selecting speeds lower than the 85th percentile of speed. The higher education level in the present study was the PhD, and results indicated that participants who were categorized in the higher level of education tried to decrease their speed more than others. Also, results indicated that drivers who selected speeds higher than the 85th percentile of speed experienced at least one accident during the driving task in the driving simulator.
Keywords
speed selection
drivers’ behavior
driving simulator
weather conditions
  • 2019. “Iranian Legal Medicine Organization (LMO).” Web-Based Death and Injury Statistics Reporting System.

 

  • Bella, Francesco, Alessandro Calvi, and Fabrizio D’Amico. 2014. “Analysis of Driver Speeds under Night Driving Conditions Using a Driving Simulator.” Journal of Safety Research 49:45.e1-52.

 

  • Brooks, Johnell O., Matthew C. Crisler, Nathan Klein, Richard Goodenough, Rebekkah W. Beeco, Chris Guirl, Peg J. Tyler, Anna Hilpert, Yarbough Miller, Jason Grygier, Brooke Burroughs, Ashley Martin, Rob Ray, Cody Palmer, and Christine Beck. 2011. “Speed Choice and Driving Performance in Simulated Foggy Conditions.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 43(3):698–705.

 

  • Broughton, Kathy L. M., Fred Switzer, and Don Scott. 2007. “Car Following Decisions under Three Visibility Conditions and Two Speeds Tested with a Driving Simulator.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 39(1):106–16.

 

  • Butters, Jennifer, Robert E. Mann, Christine M. Wickens, and Paul Boase. 2012. “Gender Differences and Demographic Influences in Perceived Concern for Driver Safety and Support for Impaired Driving Countermeasures.” Journal of Safety Research 43(5–6):405–11.

 

  • Cai, Xiaoyu, Cailin Lei, Bo Peng, Xiaoyong Tang, and Zhigang Gao. 2020. “Road Traffic Safety Risk Estimation Method Based on Vehicle Onboard Diagnostic Data” edited by B. Farooq. Journal of Advanced Transportation 2020:3024101.

 

  • Calvi, Alessandro, and Francesco Bella. 2014. “Modeling Speed Differential Parameters in Day and Night Environments Using Driving Simulator.” Pp. 648–61 in Procedia Engineering. Vol. 84. Elsevier Ltd.

 

  • Duddu, Venkata R., Venu Madhav, and Srinivas S. Pulugurtha. 2019. “Crash Risk Factors Associated with Injury Severity of Teen Drivers.” IATSS Research 43(1):37–43.

 

  • Edwards, J. B. 1999. “The Temporal Distribution of Road Accidents in Adverse Weather.” Meteorological Applications 6(1):59–68.

 

  • Edwards, Julia B. 2002. “Motorway Speeds in Wet Weather : The Comparative Influence of Porous and Conventional Asphalt Surfacings.” 10:303–11.

 

  • Fu, Xinsha, Shijian He, Jintao Du, Xiaofei Wang, and Ting Ge. 2020. “Variations in Naturalistic Driving Behavior and Visual Perception at the Entrances of Short, Medium, and Long Tunnels.” Journal of Advanced Transportation

 

  • George, Derren, and Mallery Paul. 2010. “SPSS for Windows Step by Step. A Simple Study Guide and Reference (10. Baskı).” GEN, Boston, MA: Pearson Education, Inc.

 

  • Gilandeh, Salar Sadeghi, Mansour Hadji Hosseinlou, and Alireza Jafari Anarkooli. 2018. “Examining Bus Driver Behavior as a Function of Roadway Features under Daytime and Nighttime Lighting Conditions: Driving Simulator Study.” Safety Science 110:142–51.

 

  • Hakamies-blomqvist, Liisa. 1998. “Why Do Older Drivers Give up Driving ?” Accident Analysis & Prevention 30(3):305–12.

 

  • Hamdar, Samer H., Lingqiao Qin, and Alireza Talebpour. 2016. “Weather and Road Geometry Impact on Longitudinal Driving Behavior: Exploratory Analysis Using an Empirically Supported Acceleration Modeling Framework.” Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies 67:193–213.

 

  • Harré, Niki, Theo Brandt, and Martin Dawe. 2000. “The Development of Risky Driving in Adolescence.” Journal of Safety Research 31(4):185–94.

 

  • Harré, Niki, Jeff Field, and Barry Kirkwood. 1996. “Gender Differences and Areas of Common Concern in the Driving Behaviors and Attitudes of Adolescents.” Journal of Safety Research 27(3):163–73.

 

  • Hoogendoorn, Raymond G., Serge P. Hoogendoorn, Karel A. Brookhuis, and Winnie Daamen. 2011. “Adaptation Longitudinal Driving Behavior, Mental Workload, and Psycho-Spacing Models in Fog.” Transportation Research Record 2249(1):20–28.

 

  • Jafari Anarkooli, A., and M. Hadji Hosseinlou. 2016. “Analysis of the Injury Severity of Crashes by Considering Different Lighting Conditions on Two-Lane Rural Roads.” Journal of Safety Research 56:57–65.

 

  • Kanji, Gopal K. 2006. 100 Statistical Tests. SAGE Publications.

 

  • Konstantopoulos, Panos, Peter Chapman, and David Crundall. 2010. “Driver’s Visual Attention as a Function of Driving Experience and Visibility. Using a Driving Simulator to Explore Drivers’ Eye Movements in Day, Night and Rain Driving.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 42(3):827–34.

 

  • Lee, Jooyoung, Jiho Yeo, Ilsoo Yun, and Sanghyeok Kang. 2020. “Factors Affecting Crash Involvement of Commercial Vehicle Drivers : Evaluation of Commercial Vehicle Drivers ’ Characteristics in South Korea.” Journal of Advanced Transportation

 

  • Li, Shuo, Phil Blythe, Weihong Guo, and Anil Namdeo. 2019. “Investigating the Effects of Age and Disengagement in Driving on Driver ’ s Takeover Control Performance in Highly Automated Vehicles.” Transportation Planning and Technology 42(5):470–97.

 

  • Li, Xiaomeng, Xuedong Yan, and S. C. Wong. 2015. “Effects of Fog, Driver Experience and Gender on Driving Behavior on S-Curved Road Segments.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 77:91–104.

 

  • Liu, Jing, Jing Cai, Shanshan Lin, and Jianyou Zhao. 2020. “Analysis of Factors Affecting a Driver ’ s Driving Speed Selection in Low Illumination.” 2020.

 

  • Mueller, Alexandra S., and Lana M. Trick. 2012. “Driving in Fog : The Effects of Driving Experience and Visibility on Speed Compensation and Hazard Avoidance.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 48:472–79.

 

  • Ni, Rui, Julie J. Kang, and George J. Andersen. 2010. “Age-Related Declines in Car Following Performance under Simulated Fog Conditions.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 42(3):818–26.

 

  • Oltedal, Sigve, and Torbjørn Rundmo. 2006. “The Effects of Personality and Gender on Risky Driving Behaviour and Accident Involvement.” Safety Science 44(7):621–28.

 

  • Pan, Fuquan, Yongzheng Yang, Lixia Zhang, Changxi Ma, Jinshun Yang, and Xilong Zhang. 2020. “Analysis of the Impact of Traffic Violation Monitoring on the Vehicle Speeds of Urban Main Road: Taking China as an Example.” Journal of Advanced Transportation 2020:1–11.

 

  • Papantoniou, Panagiotis, George Yannis, and Eleni Christofa. 2019a. “Which Factors Lead to Driving Errors ? A Structural Equation Model Analysis through a Driving Simulator Experiment.” IATSS Research 43(1):44–50.

 

  • Papantoniou, Panagiotis, George Yannis, and Eleni Christofa. 2019b. “Which Factors Lead to Driving Errors? A Structural Equation Model Analysis through a Driving Simulator Experiment.” IATSS Research 43(1):44–50.

 

  • Parishad, Nasser, Kayvan Aghabayk, Rose Rezaie, Alireza Samerei, and Amin Mohammadi. 2020. “Validation of the Driver Behavior Questionnaire in a Representative Sample of Iranian Drivers.” Civil Engineering Infrastructures Journal 53(1):161–71.

 

  • Peng, Yichuan, Mohamed Abdel-aty, M. Asce, Jaeyoung Lee, M. Asce, and Yajie Zou. 2018. “Analysis of the Impact of Fog-Related Reduced Visibility on Traffic Parameters.” Journal of Transportation Engineering 144(2):1–8.

 

  • Peng, Yichuan, Yuming Jiang, Jian Lu, and Yajie Zou. 2018. “Examining the Effect of Adverse Weather on Road Transportation Using Weather and Traffic Sensors.” PloS One 13(10):e0205409–e0205409.

 

  • Rahman, Ashrafur, and Nicholas E. Lownes. 2012. “Analysis of Rainfall Impacts on Platooned Vehicle Spacing and Speed.” Transportation Research Part F: Psychology and Behaviour 15(4):395–403.

 

  • Rumar, Kåre. 1998. “Lane Markings in Night Driving: A Review of Past Research.” Transportation Research Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

 

  • Thode, Henry C. 2002. Testing for Normality. Vol. 164. CRC press.

 

  • Wu, Yina, Mohamed Abdel-aty, Juneyoung Park, and Ryan M. Selby. 2018. “Effects of Real-Time Warning Systems on Driving under Fog Conditions Using an Empirically Supported Speed Choice Modeling Framework.” Transportation Research Part C 86:97–110.

 

  • Wu, Yina, Mohamed Abdel-Aty, Juneyoung Park, and Ryan M. Selby. 2018. “Effects of Real-Time Warning Systems on Driving under Fog Conditions Using an Empirically Supported Speed Choice Modeling Framework.” Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies 86(October 2017):97–110.

 

  • Yan, Xuedong, Xiaomeng Li, Yang Liu, and Jia Zhao. 2014. “Effects of Foggy Conditions on Drivers’ Speed Control Behaviors at Different Risk Levels.” Safety Science 68:275–87.

 

  • Yang, Jingsi, Xuedong Yan, Qingwan Xue, Xiaomeng Li, Ke Duan, Junyu Hang, and Wanjun Li. 2019. “Exploring the Effects of Signs ’ Design and in-Vehicle Audio Warning on Driver Behavior at Flashing-Light-Controlled Grade Crossings : A Driving Simulator-Based Study.” Journal of Advanced Transportation

 

  • Zhang, Tingru, Foroogh Hajiseyedjavadi, Yuhua Wang, Siby Samuel, and Xingda Qu. 2018. “Training Interventions Are Only Effective on Careful Drivers , Not Careless Drivers.” Transportation Research Part F: Psychology and Behaviour 58:693–707.

 

  • Zolali, Mehdi, and Babak Mirbaha. 2020. “Analysing the Effect of Foggy Weather on Drivers’ Speed Choice in Two-Lane Highways.” Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Transport 173(3):171–83.

 

  • Zolali, Mehdi, Babak Mirbaha, Maziyar Layegh, and Hamid Reza Behnood. 2021. “A Behavioral Model of Drivers’ Mean Speed Influenced by Weather Conditions, Road Geometry, and Driver Characteristics Using a Driving Simulator Study” edited by Y.-C. Lin. Advances in Civil Engineering 2021:5542905.

 

  • Zolali, Mehdi; Mirbaha, Babak; and Behnood, Hamid Reza (2021) “Impact of Drivers' Characteristics on Speed Choice Behavior in Adverse Weather Conditions: A Driving Simulator Study” Transportation Research Board 100th Annual Meeting, Washington DC, United States, 2021-1-5 to 2021-1-29.
International Journal of Transportation Engineering
Volume 9, Issue 3 - Serial Number 35
Winter 2022
Pages 713-734