Bridges Risk Analysis in View of Repair and Maintenance by Multi Criteria Decision Making Method (Case Study: Babolsar Bridges)

Document Type : Research Paper


1 Ph.D. Student, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Babol Noshirvani University of Technology, Babol, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Babol Noshirvani University of Technology, Babol, Iran

3 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Babol Noshirvani University of Technology, Babol, Iran

4 Assistant Professor, Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal


Bridges built from any material and having any special shape  will eventually show signs of wearing off; therefore, there are several factors in the kind and rate of such wearing off and its expansion such as atmosphere, flood, earthquake, overload, design quality, execution and kind of materials that will all reduce the functionality of the structures. Thus, maintaining processes and repairing the bridges may increase their life. In this article, after identifying effective risks on the bridges upon using them, critical risks are determined with FMEA method. After distinguishing the critical factors, each one is studied in details. Finally, three bridges in Bablosar (Iran), located over Babolrood River as well as their traffic role between the two sides of the city are investigated. Moreover, their roles on the traffic is also another case of interest in case with the destruction of any of these bridges, the communication to either side of the city faces serious problems. Also, the identified risks for each of these bridges are investigated to discern which of them is in no appropriate condition and if necessary they should be maintained and fortified. To do so, in this research by using AHP, ANP and Topsis Methods, these bridges are prioritized. Results show that the first bridge in this city has a worse state in comparison to the other ones and should be repaired, maintained, or fortified as soon as possible.


- Abdelgawad, M. and Fayek, A. R. (2010) “Risk in the management construction industry using combined fuzzy FMEA and fuzzy AHP”, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, Vol. 136, No. 9, pp. 1028-1036, ASCE.
- Abdollahzadeh, Gh., Taheri Amiri, M. J., Akbari Kaffash, E., Hemmatian, M. and Keyhanfard, S. (2013) “Choosing an appropriate factorial system through the modern and outmoded system by two approaches ANP and AHP-FUZZY”, Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science, Vol. 6, No. 2, pp. 110-117.
- Abdollahzadeh, Gh., Haghighi, F. and Taheri Amiri, M. J. (2014) “The appraisal of the risk in the bridges of Babolsar through the "ANP and FSAW" methods”, The Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science, Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 137-152.
- Abdollahzadeh, Gh., Haghighi, F., Taheri Amiri, M. J. and  Rstgoo, S. (2016) “Evaluation of Babolsar city bridges in utilization case from risk taking point of view seismically by using fmea-fuzzy method”, Journal of Transportation Research, Vol. 13, No. 3,  pp. 225-236.(In Persian)
- Aktan A. E., Helmicki,  A. J. and  Hunt, V. J. (1996)  “Issues related to intelligent bridge monitoring “, Proccedings of Structures Congress XIV. Ghosh SK, Mohammadi J, editors. ASCE, 2, 750-7.
- Alfieri, L. et al. (2018) "A global network for operational flood risk reduction", Environmental Science and Policy, Vol. 84, pp. 149-158.
- Bahrami, M., HadizadehBazzaz, D. and Sajjadi, M. (2012) “Innovation and improvements in project implementation and management; using FMEA Technique”, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 41, pp. 418 – 425.
- Barone, G., Frangopol, D. M. and  Soliman, M. (2014) “Optimization of life-cycle maintenance of deteriorating bridges with respect to expected annual system failure rate and expected cumulative Cost”, ASCE, Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 140, No. 2, 04013043.
- Bellman, R. E. and Zadeh L. A. “Decision-making in a fuzzy environment”, Management Sciences, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp. 141-164.
- Berthellemy, J. (2018) " Evaluation regarding fatigue for various type of hangers used for tied arch bridges", Procedia Engineering, Vol. 213, pp. 426-436.
-Bhutta, K. S. and Huq, F.  (2002) “Supplier selection problem, a comparison of the total cost of ownership and analytic hierarchy process approaches”, Supply Chain Management,  an International Journal, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 126-135.
-Dey, P. K. and Ramcharan, E. K. (2008) “Analytical Hierarchy Process Helps Select Site for Limestone Quarry Expansion in Barbodos”, Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 88, pp. 1384-1395
- Dunker, K. R. and  Rabbat, B. G. (1993) “Why America’ s bridges are crumbling”, Scientific American Magazine, Vol. 266, No. 3, pp. 66-72.
-Gholami, M., Sam, A. R. B. M. and  Yatim, J.M. (2013) “Assessment of bridge management system in Iran”, Procedia Engineering,  Vol. 54, pp. 573 – 583.
- Gschnitzer, T., Gems, B., Mazzorana, B. and Aufleger, M. (2017) "Towards a robust assessment of bridge clogging processes in flood risk management", Geomorphology, Vol. 279, pp. 128-140.
-Handfield, R. B.,  Walton, S.V., Sroufe, R. and Melynyk, S. A (2002) “Applying environmental criteria to supplier assessment: a study in the application of analytic hierarchy process”, European Journal of operational Research, Vol. 141, pp. 70-87.
-Highway Geometric Design Code, No.415”, (2013)  Office of Deputy for Strategic Supervision Department of Technical Affairs, Islamic Republic of Iran (In Persian) .
- Hu, X., Daganzo, C. and Madanat, S. (2015) “ A reliability-based optimization scheme for maintenance management in large-scale bridge networks”, Elsevier BV, Transportation Research Part C: Emerging, Vol. 55, pp. 166- 178.
- Jones, William C. (2002) "Highway bridge replacement and rehabilitation program (HBRRP)" Division Administrator, Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), U.S.A.
- Kameshwar, S. and Padgett, J. E. (2014) "Multi-hazard risk assessment of highway bridges subjected to earthquake and hurricane hazards", Engineering Structure, Vol. 74, pp. 154-166.
 - Kumru, M. and Kumru, P. (2013) “ Fuzzy FMEA application to improve purchasing process in a public hospital”,  Applied Soft Computing, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 721–733.
- Kużawa, M., Kamiński, T. and Bień, J. (2018) " Fatigue assessment procedure for old riveted road bridges", Archives of Civil and Mechanical Engineering, Vol. 18, No. 1, pp. 1259-1274.
-Leander, J., Honfi, D., Ivanov, O. L. and Bjornsson, I. (2018) " A decision support framework for fatigue assessment of steel bridges", Engineering Failure Analysis, Vol. 91, pp. 306-314.
- Lee, C. K. and Kim, S. K.  (2007) “GA-based algorithm for selecting optimal repair and rehabilitation methods for reinforced concrete (RC) bridge decks,” Automation in Construction, Vol. 16, No. 2, pp. 153–164.
-Maxwell, J. W. S.  (1990) “Highway bridge management”, First International Conference on Bridge Management, pp. 113-120, Elsevier, London.
-McIntyre, D. (1997) “Weak bridges: the impact on freight movement”. Proc. Conference on British Roads: National asset or national Disgrace, Sponsored by Surveyor Magazine and the Automobile Association
-Nazarpour, H., Taheri Amiri, M. J. and Hemmatian, M. ( 2014) “Prioritizing delay causes in construction projects in mazandaran province (Iran) and presenting solutions for improving it”, Applied Mathematics in Engineering, Management And Technology, Vol. 2, No. 4, pp.  242-253.
- Orcesi, A. D. and Frangopol, D. M. (2011a) “Optimization of bridge maintenance strategies based on structural health monitoring information”, Structural Safety, Vol. 33, No. 1, pp. 26–41
- Orcesi, A. D. and Frangopol, D. M. )2011b( “A stakeholder probability-based optimization approach for cost-effective bridge management under financial constraints”, Elsevier BV, Journal of Engineering Structures, Vol. 33, No. 5, pp. 1439- 1449.
- Ozer, I. (2007) ”Multi-criteria group decision making method using AHP and Integrated Web-Based Decision Support System”, MSc. Thesis, University of Ottawa, Canada, 2007.
- Petroski, H. (1995) “Engineers of dreams: great bridge builders and the spanning of America”, NewYork,  Allfred A. Knopf,
- Štemberk, P.,  da Silva, W. R. L.,  Sy´korova, J. and Bartova, J. (2013) “Fuzzy modeling of combined effect of winter road maintenance and cyclic loading on concrete slab bridge”, Advances in Engineering Software, Vol. 62–63, pp. 97–108.
- Rayal, M. J. (2006) “Bridge management”, 1st ed., Trans. Ministry of Roads and Transportation, Department of Education, Research, and Technology, Transportation Research Center.
- Rieetveld, P. and Ouwesloot, H. (1992) “Ordinal Data in multi-criteria decision making, a stochastic dominance approach to sitting nuclear power plants”, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 56, pp.249-262.
- Saaty, Thomas L. (1996) “Decision making with dependence and feedback", RWS Publications, Pittsburgh, PA
- Saaty, Thomas L, (1999) "Fundamentals of the Analytic Network Process", ISAHP, JAPAN: Kobe.
- Saaty, Thomas L. (2004) "Fundamentals of the Analytic Network Process "; Dependence and feedback in decision-making with a single Network, Pittsburgh: university of Pittsburgh.
-Shahabi, H., Keyhanfard, S., Bin-Ahmad, B. and Taheri Amiri, M. J. “Evaluating Boolean, AHP and WLC methods for the selection of waste landfill sites using GIS and satellite images”, Environmental Earth Sciences, Vol. 71, No. 9,  pp. 4221-4233.
- Shahabi, H., Ahmad, B., Bin-Ahmad, B., Taheri Amiri, M. J. Keyhanfard, S. and Ebrahimi, S. (2016) “Assessment of WLC and fuzzy logic methods for site selection of water reservoirs in Malaysia”, Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, Vol.  25, No 3, pp. 1-9.
- Schenkerman, S. (1994) “Avoiding rank-reversal in AHP decision support models”, European Journal of operation Research Vol. 74, pp. 407-419.
- Taheri Amiri, M. J., Javaheri Barforooshi, M. and Rastgoo, S. (2015) “Acknowledgment and priority of risk in dam-making projects by using FMEA-FUZZY”, Buletin Teknologi Maknan (Journal of Management and Engineering), Vol. 2, No 6, pp. 165-171
- Vargas, L. G. (1994) "Reply to Schenkerman s avoiding rank reversal in AHP decision support model", European Journal of operation Research, Vol. 74, pp. 420-425.
-Wang, Z., Padgett, J. E. and Duerias-Osorio, L. (2014), "Risk-consistent calibration of load factors for the design of reinforced concrete bridges under the combined effects of earthquake and scour hazards", Engineering Structures, Vol. 79, pp. 86-95.
- Xiao, Z.,  Chen, L. and Zhong, B.  (2010) “A model based on rough set theory combined with algebraic structure and its application: Bridges maintenance management evaluation”, Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 37, pp. 5295–5299.
- Yin, Z.,  Li, Y., Guo, J. and  Li, Y. (2011) “Integration research and design of the bridge maintenance management system” , Procedia Engineering, Vol. 15, pp. 5429 – 5434
- Zhang, W. and Wang, N. (2017) "Bridge network maintenance prioritization under budget constraint", Structural    Safety, Vol. 67, pp. 96-104.