Evaluation and Relocating Bicycle Sharing Stations in Mashhad City using Multi-Criteria Analysis

Document Type: Research Paper


1 MA. Grad., Department of Urban Management, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Geography, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Urban Management, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran

4 MSc. in Remote Sensing and GIS, Faculty of Geography, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran


The purpose of this study is to evaluate the present status of Mashhad’s Bicycle Sharing (BS) Program's stations, and to locate future stations, taking into account the 7 criteria of “proximity to subway stations”, “proximity to other stations”, “distance from important intersections”, “distance from population centers”, “proximity to educational, recreational and commercialcenters”, “slope level” and “proximity to cycling infrastructure (bike lanes)”. The approach employed by the present study is Multiple-criteria decision making (MCDM) and Fuzzy membership maps and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) based on GIS to weight the 7 mentioned criteria, also the stations will be ranked based on VIKOR approach and finally categorized through Jenks natural breaks classification method (JENKS). In order to analyze the data ArcGIS 10 software has been used. The findings show that 26 stations (20.3%) are very unsatisfactory and 25 stations (19.5%) are unsatisfactory among the total 128 stations that have been built so far. The findings also indicate that there are a lot of stations with very unsatisfactory conditions on the borders of the coverage area of the BS program which imply that widespread coverage has been prioritized over efficiency and proper distribution of the stations. Also 22 planned stations that have been stipulated in the contract between Mashhad’s municipality and the beneficiary firm have been located based on the ratings that were assigned. This study, as the first study with the mentioned approach on this subject in Iran shows that priorities regarding the performance of BS program may not be well conceived in different regions and cities, especially in developing countries with their own specific conditions. Thus, in this research we have tried to present the existing problems in locating the stations, and contribute to development of the existing programs and possible future programs in other cities.


- Asgharpour, M. J. (2004) "Multiple criteria decision making", Tehran University Publications.

- Ahmad, S. and De Oliveira, J. (2016) "Determinants of urban mobility in India: Lessons for promoting sustainable and inclusive urban transportation in developing countries", Transport policy, Vol. 50, pp.106-114.

- Basofi, A., Fariza, A., Ahsan, A. S. and Kamal, I. M (2015) "A comparison between natural and Head/tail breaks in LSI (Landslide Susceptibility Index) classification for landslide susceptibility mapping: A case study in Ponorogo, East Java, Indonesia", International Conference on Science in Information Technology (ICSITech), Yogyakarta, pp. 337-342.

- Bellman, R. E. and Zadeh, L. A (1970) "Decision-making in a fuzzy environment", Management Science, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp. 141–64.

- Bernatchez, A. C., Gauvin, L., Fuller, D. and Dubé, A. S., Drouin, L. (2015) "Knowing about a public bicycle share program in Montreal, Canada: Are diffusion of innovation and proximity enough for equitable awareness?” Journal of Transport & Health, Vol. 2, pp. 360-368.

- Cheng, C. H. and Mon, D. L (1994) "Evaluation weapon system by AHP based on fuzzy scales", Fuzzy Sets and Systems, Vol. 63, pp. 1–10.

- DeMaio, P. (2009) "Bike-sharing: history, impacts, models of provision, & future", Journal of Public Transport, Vol. 12, No. 4, pp. 41–56.

- Faraji Sabokbar, H. (2005) "Locating commercial service units using AHP method", Geographical Studies, Vol. 51, pp. 125-138.

- Fishman, E., Washington, S. and Haworth, N. (2013) "Bike share: a synthesis of the literature", Transport Review, Vol. 33, No. 2, pp. 148-165.

- Fishman, E., Washington, S., Haworth, N. and Mazzei, A. (2014) "Barriers to bike sharing: an analysis from Melbourne and Brisbane", Journal of Transport geography, Vol. 41, pp. 325-337.

- García-Palomares, J. C., Gutiérrez, J. and Latorre, M. (2012) "Optimizing the location of stations in bike-sharing programs: A GIS approach", Applied Geography, Vol. 35, No. 1, pp. 235-246.

- Gili, A., Álvarez, C., Bagnato, R. and Noellemeyer, E. (2017) "Comparison of three methods for delineating management zones for site-specific crop management, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture", Vol. 139, No. 15, pp. 213-223.

- Gupta, A., Bargar, A., Gupta, S. and Ma, D. (2014) "Interactive visual analytics for multi-city bikeshare data analysis", the 3rd International Workshop on Urban Computing (URBCOMP 2014), New York.

- Hwang, C. L. (1995) "Multiple attribute decision making: an introduction", SAGE, pp. 3-36.

- Herath, G. (2004) "Incorporating community objectives in improved wetland management: the use of the analytic hierarchy process", Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 70, pp. 263–273.

- Institute for Transportation and Development Policy (2013) “the bike-share planning guide", New York: ITDP.

- Jahanshahi, D., Kharazmi, O. and Ajza Shokouhi, M. (2018) "How barriers and motivators can affect Mashhad citizens' usage of bicycle sharing system: A qualitative approach", Studies of Architecture, Urbanism and Environmental Sciences Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 29-38.

- Javadi, Q. and Aqa Muhammadi, M. (2014) "Spatial planning of public bs program using gis & multi criteria decision Making", Journal of Science and Technologies of Surveying Engineering. Vol. 3, No. 4, pp. 53-64.

- Jenks, G. F. (1967) "The data model concept in statistical mapping", International Yearbook of Cartography, Vol. 7, pp. 186–190.

- Jill, C. and Roger, H. (2013) "Business research: A practical guide for undergraduate and postgraduate students (Revised ed.)", Palgrave Macmillan, ISBN 9781137037480, Retrieved 2016-05-02.

- Karki, T. K. and Tao, L. (2016) "How accessible and convenient are the public bicycle sharing programs in china? Experiences from Suzhou city", Habitat International, Vol. 53, pp. 188-194.

- Khakpour, B. and Bavanpouri, A. (2009) "An analysis on imbalanced development of mashhad", The Journal of Knowledge and Development, Vol. 27, pp. 182-202.

- Khalili, M. and Haydari Nouri, P. (2014) "Relocating bicycle sharing stations to increase accessibility and quality of non-motor transportation using GIS and presenting encouraging approaches (Case Study: District 8 of Tehran)", 14th International Conference of Transportation and Traffic, Tehran.

- Khan, F. (2012) "An initial seed selection algorithm for k-means clustering of georeferenced data to improve replicability of cluster assignments for mapping application", Applied Soft Computing, Vol. 12, No. 11, pp. 3698-3700.

- Lee, AR (1995) "Application of modified fuzzy AHP method to analyze bolting sequence of structural joints", UMI Dissertation Service, A Bell & Howell Company.

- Li, H. X., Chen, L. P. and Hung, H. P. (2001) "Fuzzy neural intelligent systems: mathematical fundamentals and application in engineering". CRC Press. pp. 4-18.

- Marshall, C. and Gretchen B. R (1999) "Designing Qualitative Research" 3rd Ed. London: Sage Publications, pp. 115

- Midgley, P (2011) "Bicycle-sharing schemes: Enhancing sustainable mobility in urban areas", New York: United Nations department of economics and social affairs.

- Minaei, M (2009) "Implementation of Agricultural Planning Model Using Fuzzy Logic and Geographic Information System (GIS)", MSc. Thesis. Faculty of Geography, Tehran University.

- Minaei, M. and Kainz, W (2016) "Watershed Land Cover/Land Use Mapping Using Remote Sensing and Data Mining in Gorganrood, Iran". ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, Vol. 5, No. 5, pp. 1-16.

- Moteallemi, A., Bina, B., Minaei, M. and Mortezaie, S (2017) "The evaluation of Noise Pollution at Samen district in Mashhad by means of Geographic Information System (GIS)", International Journal of Occupational Hygiene, Vol.9, No. 4, pp. 31-46.

- Naeimi, M., Alimoradi, Z., Razi., M. and Monajjem, S (2013) " Developing A Priority-Based Decision Making Mod To Evaluate Geometric Configuration Of Urban Interchanges", International Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 285-310.

- National Association of City Transit Officials "NACTO" (2015) "Walkable station spacing is key to successful, equitable bike share", New York: NACTO.

- Navabakhsh, M. and Bazrafshan, M. (2014) "Sustainable Urban Development in Shiraz in the Past 10 Years", Iranian Journal of Social Development, Vol. 3, pp. 49-69.

- Nikpour, A., Malekshahi, Q. and Rezqi Rami, F. (2015) "Evaluation of Sustainable Urban Development Indicators with an Emphasis on Equity in the Distribution of Services (Case study: City of Babol)", Urban Research and Planning Publication, Vol. 22, pp. 125-138.

- Opricovic, S. and Tzeng, G. H. (2004) "Compromise solution by MCDM methods: A comparative analysis of VIKOR and TOPSIS", Euro. J. Oper. Res., Vol. 156, No. 2, pp. 445–455.

- Opricovic, S. and Tzeng, G. H. (2007) "Extended VIKOR method in comparison with out ranking methods", Euro. J. Operational Rewsearch,  Vol. 178, pp. 514–529.

- Randall, P., Brown, L., Deschaine, L., Dimarzio, J., Kaiser, G. and Vierow, J. (2004) "Application of the analytic hierarchy process to compare alternatives for the long-term management of surplus mercury", Journal of Environmental Management Vol. 71, pp. 35–43.

- Roland Berger Study (2015) April 23. Retrieved from http://www.rolandberger.com/press_releases/bike-sharing-4-0.html

- Saaty, T. L. (1980) "The analytic hierarchy process", New York: Wiley

- Shaheen, S. A., Guzman, S. and Zhang, H. (2010) "Bikesharing in Europe, the Americas, and Asia", Transportation Research Board, pp.159-167.

- Shaheen, S. A., Zhang, H., Martin, E. and Guzman, S. (2011) "China Hangzhou public bicycle. Understanding early adoption and behavioral response to bikesharing", Journal of Transportation Research Board, Vol. 2247, pp.33-41.

- Soghab Isfahani, I., Hakimi Khaki, A., Pakdel, P., Moqadam Husseini, S. A., Haydarzadeh, E. and Shakouri, J. (2013) "The paths taken and not taken", (Documentary of activities and Experiences of Mashhad’s Municipality 1989-2013). Mashhad: Ahange Qalam Publications.

- Soltani, A. and Shariati, S. (2013) "Examining the incentives and disincentives for the use of bicycles in urban transport (case study of Isfahan)", Journal of the Association of Iranian Architectural, Vol. 5, pp. 63-73.

- Tran, T. D., Ovtracht, N. and d'Arcier, B. F. (2015) "Modeling bike sharing system using built environment factors", CIRP, Vol. 30, pp. 293-298.

- Zadeh, L. A. (1965) "Fuzzy set", Information and Control, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 338–53.

- Zhu, A. X., Wang, R., Qiao, J., Qin, C. Z., Chen, Y., Liu, J., Du, F., Lin, Y. and Zhu, T. (2014) "An expert knowledge-based approach to landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS and fuzzy logic", Geomorphology. Vol. 214, pp. 128-138