Comparing Public Transport Alternatives Using AHP-TOPSIS and Sustainability Indicators -Case Study: City of Isfahan

Document Type: Research Paper


1 PhD Student, Department of Transportation Engineering, Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran

2 Professor of Urban Planning and Transportation. Department of Civil Engineering, Architecture and Georessources, Instituto Superior Técnico/CiTUA, University of Lisbon. Portugal

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Transportation Engineering, Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran



This paper concerns the problem of decision making on the selection of public transportation modes. The problem is formulated through sustainability indicators and the objective framework is based upon AHP-TOPSIS. In this research, the city of Isfahan (Iran) is our case study. The definition of different points of view was developed through interviews to stakeholders, experts in transportation and urban planning as well as end-users. In this regard, feasible alternatives of public transport modes, such as Metro, Tramway (Light Rapid Transit) Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) and Regular Bus (RB) were compared for demand corridors with similar characteristics and operating conditions. Besides, different aspects and criteria of sustainable transportation including economic, social and environmental dimensions are taken into consideration. Our findings address different orders of desirability and the suitability of public transport modes. In the view of end-users, Metro and Tramway are the most desirable modes due chiefly to service quality factors such as minimal travel time and comfort-ability. However, the local government is more interested to reduce total costs and therefore, the recommended alternatives are BRT and RB. To consolidate these results, an interview is conducted; city council members as well as senior experts in traffic and transportation fields are surveyed.  


- Awasthi, A., Chauhan, S. S. and Omrani, H. (2011) "Application of fuzzy TOPSIS in evaluating sustainable transportation systems “, Expert systems with Applications, Vol. 38, No.10, pp.12270-12280.

- Baradaran, V. (2017) "Assessment and prioritizing the risks of urban rail transportation using Grey Analytical Hierarchy Process (GAHP) ", International Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol.4, No.4,  pp.255-273.

- Beheshtinia, M. A., and Ahangareian, M. (2018) "A new hybrid decision making method for selecting roller concrete road pavement technology transfer method", International Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol. 5, No. 3, pp.229-242.

- Bilişik, Ö. N., Erdoğan, M., Kaya, İ. and Baraçlı, H. (2013) "A hybrid fuzzy methodology to evaluate customer satisfaction in a public transportation system for Istanbul ", Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, Vol. 24, No.9-10, pp.1141-1159.

- Boulange, C., Gunn, L., Giles-Corti, B., Mavoa, S., Pettit, C., and Badland,  H.  (2017) "Examining associations between urban design attributes and transport mode choice for walking, cycling, public transport and private motor vehicle trips “, Journal of Transport and Health, Vol. 6, pp.155-166.

- Büyüközkan, G., Feyzioğlu, O., and Göçer, F. (2018) "Selection of sustainable urban transportation alternatives using an integrated intuitionistic fuzzy Choquet integral approach “, Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, Vol.58, pp. 186-207.

- d'Arcier, B. F. (2014) "Measuring the performance of urban public transport in relation to public policy objectives “, Research in Transportation Economics, Vol. 48, pp. 67-76.

-          e Costa, C. A. B., Ensslin, L., Cornêa, É. C., and Vansnick, J. C. (1999) "Decision support systems in action: integrated application in a multicriteria decision aid process “, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.113, No.2, pp. 315-335.

- e Costa, C. A. B., Lourenço, J. C., Oliveira, M. D. and e Costa, J. C. B. (2014) "A socio-technical approach for group decision support in public strategic planning: the Pernambuco PPA case ", Group Decision and Negotiation, Vol.23, No.1, pp. 5-29.

-Ferreira, F. A. and Santos, S. P. (2016) "Comparing trade-off adjustments in credit risk analysis of mortgage loans using AHP, Delphi and MACBETH “, International Journal of Strategic Property Management, Vol. 20, No.1, pp. 44-63.

- Ghorbanzadeh, O., Moslem, S., Blaschke, T., and Duleba, S. (2019) Sustainable urban transport planning considering different stakeholder groups by an interval-AHP decision support model. Sustainability, Vol.11, No.1, pp. 1-18.

- Gilbert, R., Irwin, N., Hollingworth, B., and Blais, P. (2003) "Sustainable Transportation Performance Indicators (STPI) “, Transportation Research Board (TRB) CD ROM.

- Gudmundsson, H., P.Hall, R., Marsden, G., Zietsman, J. (2016) "Sustainable Transportation Indicators, Frameworks, and Performance Management “, Springer.

- Haghshenas, H., and Vaziri, M. (2012) "Urban sustainable transportation indicators for global comparison “, Ecological Indicators, Vol.15, No.1, pp.115-121.

- Haghshenas, H., Vaziri, M. and Gholamialam, A. (2015) "Evaluation of sustainable policy in urban transportation using system dynamics and world cities data: A case study in Isfahan “, Cities, Vol.45, pp.104-115.

- Hassan, M. N., Hawas, Y. E. and Ahmed, K. (2013) "A multi-dimensional framework for evaluating the transit service performance “, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, Vol.50, pp. 47-61.

- Jahanshahi, D., Minaei, M., Kharazmi, O. A. and Minaei, F. (2019) "Evaluation and Relocating Bicycle Sharing Stations in Mashhad City using Multi-Criteria Analysis", International Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol.6, No.3, pp.265-283.

- Jain, S., Aggarwal, P., Kumar, P., Singhal, S., and Sharma, P. (2014) "Identifying public preferences using multi-criteria decision making for assessing the shift of urban commuters from private to public transport: A case study of Delhi“, Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, Vol. 24, pp.60-70.

- Jönson, G. and Tengström, E. (Eds.) (2006) "Urban transport development: a complex issue “, Springer Science and Business Media.

- Litman, T. (2016) "Well measured: developing indicators for sustainable and livable transport planning", Victoria Transport Policy Institute.

- Luathep, P., Suttipan, S. and  Jaensirisak, S. (2015) "Challenge of public transport planning in private vehicle dominated community", Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol. 11, pp. 1122-1139.

- Macharis, C. and Bernardini, A. (2015) "Reviewing the use of multi-criteria decision analysis for the evaluation of transport projects: Time for a multi-actor approach “, Transport Policy, Vol. 37, pp.177-186.

- Mahmoudi, R., Shetab-Boushehri, S. N., Hejazi, S. R. and Emrouznejad, A. (2019) Determining the relative importance of sustainability evaluation criteria of urban transportation network. Sustainable Cities and Society, Vol. 47, pp.101493.

- Mansourianfar, M. H. and Haghshenas, H. (2018) "Micro-scale sustainability assessment of infrastructure projects on urban transportation systems: Case study of Azadi district, Isfahan, Iran “, Cities, Vol. 72, pp. 149-159.

- Mardani, A., Zavadskas, E. K., Khalifah, Z., Jusoh, A. and Nor, K. M. (2016) "Multi criteria decision-making techniques in transportation systems: A systematic review of the state of the art literature “, Transport, Vol.31, No.3, pp.359-385.

- Naeimi, M., Alimoradi, Z., Razi, M. and Monajjem, S. (2014) "Developing a priority-based decision making mod to evaluate geometric configuration of urban interchanges”, International Journal of Transpotation Engineering, Vol.1, No.4,  pp. 285-310.

- Ramani, T. L., and Zietsman, J. (2016) "Sustainable transportation–alternative perspectives and enduring challenges“, International Journal of Urban Sciences, Vol.20, No.3, pp.318-333.

- Reisi, M., Aye, L., Rajabifard, A. and Ngo, T. (2016) "Land-use planning: Implications for transport sustainability “, Land use policy, Vol. 50, pp.252-261.

- Robert, K. W., Parris, T. M. and Leiserowitz, A. A. (2005) "What is sustainable development? Goals, indicators, values, and practice “, Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, Vol.47, No.3, pp. 8-21.

- Salavati, A., Haghshenas, H., Ghadirifaraz, B., Laghaei, J. and Eftekhari, G. (2016) "Applying AHP and clustering approaches for public transportation decision making: a case study of Isfahan City“, Journal of Public Transportation, Vol.19, No.4, pp.38-55.

- Tzeng, G. H. and Huang, J. J. (2011) "Multiple attribute decision making: methods and applications “, Chapman and Hall/CRC.

- Van Kamp, I., Leidelmeijer, K.,  Marsman, G. and De Hollander, A. (2003) "Urban environmental quality and human well-being: Towards a conceptual framework and demarcation of concepts; a literature study”, Landscape and urban planning, Vol.65, No.1-2, pp.5-18.

- Vuchic, V. R. 2007. Urban Transit, Systems and Technology. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 2007.

- Wann-Ming, W. (2019) "Constructing urban dynamic transportation planning strategies for improving quality of life and urban sustainability under emerging growth management principles “, Sustainable Cities and Society, Vol. 44, pp. 275-290.

- Yu, J., Wang, L. and Gong, X. (2013)  "Study on the status evaluation of urban road intersections traffic congestion base on AHP-TOPSIS modal “, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 96, pp. 609-616.